I need you to consider ditching T-Mobile, Verizon and AT&T for Starlink soon. It's for the Big 3's own good!

Join the discussion
DFranch
DFranch
Arena Master
• 1mo ago
↵stferrari said:

I never said helping people wasn't a good thing. I said it wasn't the government's duty to do so. There is now where in scripture where God states that it is. You are projecting your opinions into scripture. Per scripture:


This means the poor and foreigner need to work and collect their own crops.

Thessalonians 3:10, "The one who is unwilling to work shall not eat".

Again, the Bible does not contain an explicit command or directive for one civil government to provide foreign aid or financial assistance to another government.


To summarizeKey Biblical Principles Regarding Government and Aid

  • Scope of Civil Government: Scripture outlines the primary role of civil government as maintaining law and order, administering justice, punishing wrongdoing, and protecting the vulnerable (such as in Romans 13:1–4 and 1 Peter 2:13–14). It does not outline a modern framework or mandate for state-to-state foreign aid. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
  • Individual and Communal Charity: Biblical commands to love your neighbor, feed the hungry, and care for the poor (e.g., Deuteronomy 15:7–11) are addressed primarily to individuals, families, and the faith community rather than assigned as a structural or diplomatic obligation between sovereign nations. [1, 2, 3]
  • Ancient Israel vs. Modern Nations: Ancient Israel operated as a theocratic nation-state with specific, localized covenantal laws (such as the Jubilee year or gleaning laws). Analysts note that Israel's unique status cannot be directly mapped onto modern secular or pluralistic foreign policies. [1, 2]
  • Theological Perspectives: Christian thinkers hold varying views. Some argue that governments have a general moral duty to promote justice and mercy broadly, while others maintain that foreign aid is a matter of prudential statecraft and political judgment rather than a binding scriptural command. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]

My contention was never that not helping others was not a righteous and moral thing, it was refuting your contention that the one goverment was biblically commanded to do so. If you choose to reinterpret scripture to fit your beliefs then do so. Just don't try and criticize my interpretation of scripture. I do not answer to your beliefs and or opinions. I answer only to my Father God.

I suppose if the world today resembled the world 2000 years ago, you might have a point, but today trips that used to take months take hours. Disease which would be contained 2000 years ago can spread worldwide in days.

Helping others in many cases helps us. Giving aid for HIV treatment & prevention, malaria prevention, tuberculosis control, vaccines, doesn't just help the foreign countries, it helps us as well. Shutting down an agency that provides these benefits is completely shortsighted, and a little evil.

Like
Quote
stferrari
stferrari
Arena Master
• 1mo ago
↵DFranch said:

I suppose if the world today resembled the world 2000 years ago, you might have a point, but today trips that used to take months take hours. Disease which would be contained 2000 years ago can spread worldwide in days.

Helping others in many cases helps us. Giving aid for HIV treatment & prevention, malaria prevention, tuberculosis control, vaccines, doesn't just help the foreign countries, it helps us as well. Shutting down an agency that provides these benefits is completely shortsighted, and a little evil.

Now your stating your opinion/political stance and not scripture. Again, I am all for providing anyone in the world with aid but we dissagree on how this should be done and who should do it. The federal government constitutionality states the federal government is only to provide for the domestic populous. The size and spending of of government has gotten way way out of control and needs some very serious fiscal pruning. Just my opinion however. Have a blessed day and I wish you all wellness and prosperity.

Like
Quote
Doakie
Doakie
Arena Master
• 1mo ago
↵TruthOverEverything said:

I am never spending any money with any company or on any product or service that involves Elon Musk. Starlink is dead on arival to me. I hope it fails.

Must be horrible to have mental illness.

Like
Quote
Mikec7
Mikec7
Arena Apprentice
• 1mo ago
↵Naoki13 said:

Mint is a better 4th alternative, imo.

Mint is not a 4th as it's owned by t mobile.

Like
Quote
Mikec7
Mikec7
Arena Apprentice
• 1mo ago
↵Bruce_Wayne said:

A. It's Elon Musk.

B. It's Starlink, aka satellite connectivity. It's not going to be optimum in all conditions.

C. I'm Batman. I can do whatever. The carriers answer to ME.

Because it's Elon musk it has a good chance of working out. Also batman had a rich donor alot like musk.

Like
Quote