I need you to consider ditching T-Mobile, Verizon and AT&T for Starlink soon. It's for the Big 3's own good!

Join the discussion
DFranch
DFranch
Arena Master
• 1mo ago
↵stferrari said:

I think you have been reading a lot of liberal nonsense. You are obviously not a conservative but that's ok as it takes all kinds. Given he is currently the richest man in the world, I am sure he won't miss your patronage. As far as his reducing the size of the US federal government, the only thing I regret is he didn't go near far enough. The primary role of the federal government under the U.S. Constitution is to exercise only those specific, enumerated powers delegated to it—such as providing for the common defense, regulating interstate and foreign commerce, coining money, and conducting foreign policy—while leaving all other unassigned powers to the states or the people. The unconstitutional bureaucratic bloat in the government we now have is ridiculous.

Reducing the size of government isn't a bad thing. Assuming it is done with the proper research. This article does a better job of showing the proper way vs. the DOGE way:

https://www.newsweek.com/how-bill-clinton-shrunk-federal-government-30-years-before-doge-2032893

Like
1
Quote
stferrari
stferrari
Arena Master
• 1mo ago
↵DFranch said:

Reducing the size of government isn't a bad thing. Assuming it is done with the proper research. This article does a better job of showing the proper way vs. the DOGE way:

https://www.newsweek.com/how-bill-clinton-shrunk-federal-government-30-years-before-doge-2032893

I respectfully disagree overall but as with anything some points are valid. Given that the federal government has no business in areas like education, reproductive rights, gun control, etc., i dissagree with reductions in goverments employees in these areas and am more for elimination. This is only my personal opinion, some will dissagree and that's ok. My views/beliefs are rooted in scripture so my views are always going to be congruent with its teachings.

Like
Quote
DFranch
DFranch
Arena Master
• 1mo ago
↵stferrari said:

I respectfully disagree overall but as with anything some points are valid. Given that the federal government has no business in areas like education, reproductive rights, gun control, etc., i dissagree with reductions in goverments employees in these areas and am more for elimination. This is only my personal opinion, some will dissagree and that's ok. My views/beliefs are rooted in scripture so my views are always going to be congruent with its teachings.

I would assume that your "beliefs rooted in scripture" would be against the shuttering of USAID which actively funded programs that directly prevent deaths, including HIV treatment, malaria prevention, tuberculosis control, maternal health, nutrition, vaccines, clean water, and emergency humanitarian relief.

Like
Quote
stferrari
stferrari
Arena Master
• 1mo ago
↵DFranch said:

I would assume that your "beliefs rooted in scripture" would be against the shuttering of USAID which actively funded programs that directly prevent deaths, including HIV treatment, malaria prevention, tuberculosis control, maternal health, nutrition, vaccines, clean water, and emergency humanitarian relief.

Scripture states God created governments to a.) protect their countries innocent and b.) punish the guilty. Biblicaly it is not the government's responsibility to provide aid to other countries. This responsibility falls on the charitable contributions of the church, individuals and charitable organizations. By definition any given countries only obligation is their own citizens.

Like
Quote
DFranch
DFranch
Arena Master
• 1mo agoedited
↵stferrari said:

Scripture states God created governments to a.) protect their countries innocent and b.) punish the guilty. Biblicaly it is not the government's responsibility to provide aid to other countries. This responsibility falls on the charitable contributions of the church, individuals and charitable organizations. By definition any given countries only obligation is their own citizens.

The New Testament teaches that civil government is intended to restrain wrongdoing and promote justice:

  • In Romans 13:1-4, Paul says that governing authorities have been established by God and that rulers are meant to punish wrongdoers and serve "for your good." [biblegateway.com], [biblehub.com]
  • In 1 Peter 2:13-14, Peter says governors are sent "to punish those who do wrong and to praise those who do right." [biblehub.com], [biblegateway.com]


However, the specific claim "Scripture states God created governments to protect their country's innocent" is a paraphrase, not a direct biblical quotation. Scripture does not explicitly say government's sole purpose is to "protect their country" in a nationalistic sense. Rather, the passages emphasize protecting the good and punishing wrongdoing within society. [biblegateway.com], [biblehub.com]


In other words, the part about only caring about your specific country is your personal belief, not scripture.

Like
Quote
stferrari
stferrari
Arena Master
• 1mo agoedited
↵DFranch said:

The New Testament teaches that civil government is intended to restrain wrongdoing and promote justice:

  • In Romans 13:1-4, Paul says that governing authorities have been established by God and that rulers are meant to punish wrongdoers and serve "for your good." [biblegateway.com], [biblehub.com]
  • In 1 Peter 2:13-14, Peter says governors are sent "to punish those who do wrong and to praise those who do right." [biblehub.com], [biblegateway.com]


However, the specific claim "Scripture states God created governments to protect their country's innocent" is a paraphrase, not a direct biblical quotation. Scripture does not explicitly say government's sole purpose is to "protect their country" in a nationalistic sense. Rather, the passages emphasize protecting the good and punishing wrongdoing within society. [biblegateway.com], [biblehub.com]


In other words, the part about only caring about your specific country is your personal belief, not scripture.

It is my and many other people's (including Frank Turek, Charlie Kirk and many others) interpretation of scripture given God appointed leaders over each country to govern said country. Why would each country have their own leadership if not to execute his laws. By the way those how do right is synonymous with "the innocent" as innocence but definition is "not being guilty of a crime, lacking harmful intent, or having no experience with the evil in the world". If God did what want each leader to rule his own people only, why appoint a leader for each country.

Like
Quote
DFranch
DFranch
Arena Master
• 1mo agoedited
↵stferrari said:

It is my and many other people's (including Frank Turek, Charlie Kirk and many others) interpretation of scripture given God appointed leaders over each country to govern said country. Why would each country have their own leadership if not to execute his laws. By the way those how do right is synonymous with "the innocent" as innocence but definition is "not being guilty of a crime, lacking harmful intent, or having no experience with the evil in the world". If God did what want each leader to rule his own people only, why appoint a leader for each country.

I suppose that's an interpretation of scripture. IDK if you can still call it scripture though if it is as interpreted by Right Wing conservatives. That sounds like a political take on religion to support a specific belief rather than a true interpretation of the bible. Maybe stop saying you live by scripture.

Religion does not have borders, by that logic, maybe the Pope should only preach to those who live in Vatican city, not the entire world?

Nowhere in the bible does it mention helping others should be limited to the border of the country you live in.

Like
Quote
stferrari
stferrari
Arena Master
• 1mo ago
↵DFranch said:

I suppose that's an interpretation of scripture. IDK if you can still call it scripture though if it is as interpreted by Right Wing conservatives. That sounds like a political take on religion to support a specific belief rather than a true interpretation of the bible. Maybe stop saying you live by scripture.

Religion does not have borders, by that logic, maybe the Pope should only preach to those who live in Vatican city, not the entire world?

Nowhere in the bible does it mention helping others should be limited to the border of the country you live in.

Christian thinkers argue that the Bible recognizes legitimate local governance and a government's primary duty of care and order toward its own citizens first (such as family and household responsibility outlined in 1 Timothy 5:8). Some conservative financial or political interpretations also question whether compulsory state-driven foreign aid (which requires taxation or government redistribution) is a biblical mandate for the civil government, arguing that charity is fundamentally a voluntary, moral duty for the church and individuals rather than a structural role of the state.

Helping others and loving your neighbors is absolutely biblical and i personally have contributed to international aid, however nowhere in the bible does it mention the government of on nation requiring their citizens tithing (which is loosely a biblical form of taxation) being used to provide aid to other nations. You are 100% correct in that Christianity does not have borders but nations do.

  • Acts 17:26: States that God made all nations from one man and "determined the times set for them and the exact places where they should live" (or the boundaries of their dwelling place). [1]
  • Deuteronomy 32:8: Notes that "when the Most High gave to the nations their inheritance, when he divided mankind, he fixed the borders of the peoples". [1]
  • Genesis 11 (The Tower of Babel): Describes God scattering people across the earth and creating distinct languages and groups, which formed early national separation. [1, 2]
  • Numbers 34:1–12 & Joshua 1:4: Show God explicitly defining the specific physical and tribal borders of the land of Israel. [1, 2]


You are conflating a govenments duty with a Christians duty.

Like
Quote
DFranch
DFranch
Arena Master
• 1mo ago
↵stferrari said:

Christian thinkers argue that the Bible recognizes legitimate local governance and a government's primary duty of care and order toward its own citizens first (such as family and household responsibility outlined in 1 Timothy 5:8). Some conservative financial or political interpretations also question whether compulsory state-driven foreign aid (which requires taxation or government redistribution) is a biblical mandate for the civil government, arguing that charity is fundamentally a voluntary, moral duty for the church and individuals rather than a structural role of the state.

Helping others and loving your neighbors is absolutely biblical and i personally have contributed to international aid, however nowhere in the bible does it mention the government of on nation requiring their citizens tithing (which is loosely a biblical form of taxation) being used to provide aid to other nations. You are 100% correct in that Christianity does not have borders but nations do.

  • Acts 17:26: States that God made all nations from one man and "determined the times set for them and the exact places where they should live" (or the boundaries of their dwelling place). [1]
  • Deuteronomy 32:8: Notes that "when the Most High gave to the nations their inheritance, when he divided mankind, he fixed the borders of the peoples". [1]
  • Genesis 11 (The Tower of Babel): Describes God scattering people across the earth and creating distinct languages and groups, which formed early national separation. [1, 2]
  • Numbers 34:1–12 & Joshua 1:4: Show God explicitly defining the specific physical and tribal borders of the land of Israel. [1, 2]


You are conflating a govenments duty with a Christians duty.

You said "My views/beliefs are rooted in scripture so my views are always going to be congruent with its teachings". Your words, not mine.

If that were true, helping others is a good thing regardless of where they live. It appears you have determined that it's bad for the USA to help people in other countries because of your own political beliefs. Stop saying you live by scripture, you clearly don't. You live by your political beliefs.

Like
Quote
stferrari
stferrari
Arena Master
• 1mo agoedited
↵DFranch said:

You said "My views/beliefs are rooted in scripture so my views are always going to be congruent with its teachings". Your words, not mine.

If that were true, helping others is a good thing regardless of where they live. It appears you have determined that it's bad for the USA to help people in other countries because of your own political beliefs. Stop saying you live by scripture, you clearly don't. You live by your political beliefs.

I never said helping people wasn't a good thing. I said it wasn't the government's duty to do so. There is now where in scripture where God states that it is. You are projecting your opinions into scripture. Per scripture:


This means the poor and foreigner need to work and collect their own crops.

Thessalonians 3:10, "The one who is unwilling to work shall not eat".

Again, the Bible does not contain an explicit command or directive for one civil government to provide foreign aid or financial assistance to another government.


To summarizeKey Biblical Principles Regarding Government and Aid

  • Scope of Civil Government: Scripture outlines the primary role of civil government as maintaining law and order, administering justice, punishing wrongdoing, and protecting the vulnerable (such as in Romans 13:1–4 and 1 Peter 2:13–14). It does not outline a modern framework or mandate for state-to-state foreign aid. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
  • Individual and Communal Charity: Biblical commands to love your neighbor, feed the hungry, and care for the poor (e.g., Deuteronomy 15:7–11) are addressed primarily to individuals, families, and the faith community rather than assigned as a structural or diplomatic obligation between sovereign nations. [1, 2, 3]
  • Ancient Israel vs. Modern Nations: Ancient Israel operated as a theocratic nation-state with specific, localized covenantal laws (such as the Jubilee year or gleaning laws). Analysts note that Israel's unique status cannot be directly mapped onto modern secular or pluralistic foreign policies. [1, 2]
  • Theological Perspectives: Christian thinkers hold varying views. Some argue that governments have a general moral duty to promote justice and mercy broadly, while others maintain that foreign aid is a matter of prudential statecraft and political judgment rather than a binding scriptural command. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]

My contention was never that not helping others was not a righteous and moral thing, it was refuting your contention that the one goverment was biblically commanded to do so. If you choose to reinterpret scripture to fit your beliefs then do so. Just don't try and criticize my interpretation of scripture. I do not answer to your beliefs and or opinions. I answer only to my Father God.

Like
Quote