Discussion - I tested the Pixel 11 Pro XL’s new 5X Portrait Mode against the iPhone and Galaxy

Read Full Article…
Join the discussion
Victor Hristov
Victor Hristov
Phonearena team
• 1mo ago
↵TuGa121 said:

While I don't use the camera features that heavily, I have noticed for a few years that PhoneArena consistently ranks Samsung at the top, even when it appears to be outperformed by other major tech outlets. For example, when I compared the S25 Ultra against my iPhone 16 Pro Max last year, the Samsung didn't stand a chance. It’s strange because my personal experience aligned with the findings from sites like DXOMARK, which contradict the rankings I see here. It’s just surprising to see such a consistent discrepancy.

I’ve alos noticed a recurring discrepancy between your benchmarks and my own real-world testing. Specifically, when comparing the iPhone 17 Pro Max and the Galaxy Fold 8 Ultra, my own testing consistently shows the iPhone outperforming the Samsung in CPU benchmarks, yet your articles frequently claim higher multicore performance for the Snapdragon-powered Galaxy. As someone who owns and tests both devices, these results feel inaccurate; could you clarify your testing methodology or explain why your findings consistently differ from both user experience and other industry benchmarks?

Of course, we have separate pages for just our benchmarks that you can find from the "Benchmarks" section on the website. For example. this is the Performance Benchmark page and at the bottom you can see how we run our tests: https://www.phonearena.com/phones/benchmarks/performance


We have similar pages explaining our testing process for battery life, display quality, camera quality and how our review rating is formed.


For performance benchmarks, it's really strange that you are seeing different results. We usually run the benchmarks on a cold phone at room temperature and I think the results are quite consistent.


Camera testing is more complex, and it's incredibly difficult to test everything in a camera, but you can find the detailed explanation at the camera test page here: https://www.phonearena.com/phones/benchmarks/camera

Like
Quote
TuGa121
TuGa121
Arena Master
• 1mo agoedited
↵VictorHristov said:

Of course, we have separate pages for just our benchmarks that you can find from the "Benchmarks" section on the website. For example. this is the Performance Benchmark page and at the bottom you can see how we run our tests: https://www.phonearena.com/phones/benchmarks/performance


We have similar pages explaining our testing process for battery life, display quality, camera quality and how our review rating is formed.


For performance benchmarks, it's really strange that you are seeing different results. We usually run the benchmarks on a cold phone at room temperature and I think the results are quite consistent.


Camera testing is more complex, and it's incredibly difficult to test everything in a camera, but you can find the detailed explanation at the camera test page here: https://www.phonearena.com/phones/benchmarks/camera

It is confusing that other major tech outlets like GSMArena and DxOMark consistently align with my own real-world testing and benchmarks, while PhoneArena’s results frequently diverge. When multiple reputable sources report similar findings within a small margin of error, but PhoneArena shows significantly different data, it raises questions about the accuracy of your testing methodology. I have personally compared my iPhone against Samsung’s S-series and Fold devices, and the performance gap is consistently wider than what your articles suggest. If the difference were only a few percentage points, I would understand, but we are looking at a massive performance gap that warrants a closer look at your testing methodology.

Like
Quote
stferrari
stferrari
Arena Master
• 1mo agoedited
↵VictorHristov said:

Of course, we have separate pages for just our benchmarks that you can find from the "Benchmarks" section on the website. For example. this is the Performance Benchmark page and at the bottom you can see how we run our tests: https://www.phonearena.com/phones/benchmarks/performance


We have similar pages explaining our testing process for battery life, display quality, camera quality and how our review rating is formed.


For performance benchmarks, it's really strange that you are seeing different results. We usually run the benchmarks on a cold phone at room temperature and I think the results are quite consistent.


Camera testing is more complex, and it's incredibly difficult to test everything in a camera, but you can find the detailed explanation at the camera test page here: https://www.phonearena.com/phones/benchmarks/camera

Actually, GSMArena agrees with PhoneArena benchmark results. The S27 Ultra has significantly higher Geekbench 6 results than the Iphone Pro Max.

Like
Quote
Bruce_Wayne
Bruce_Wayne
Arena Legend
• 1mo ago
↵stferrari said:

Wait. Am i reading this right. Both the Samsung Galaxy Ultra and Pixel beat an Iphone? Scandalous!

Tuga is crying somewhere in a corner.

Like
Quote